Browser choice is only meaningful when users can select their preferred browser and continue using it as intended. The Browser Choice Alliance’s recent consumer survey examined what happens after Windows users make that choice—and finds that many users report encountering experiences that interfere with their ability to maintain their preferred browser settings.
The BCA survey found that Windows users have repeatedly experienced their choices being reset and overruled by Microsoft, even after making their own default preferences clear.
A browser ecosystem that supports meaningful choice requires users to have the ability to select a browser, maintain that choice and use it seamlessly over time. But 3 in 5 users reported feeling upset about browser changes being made without their consent, and nearly 1 in 2 reported moderate or high levels of concern with their ability to select and run the browser of their choice. Among users who have selected a browser other than Edge, 29% reported that Windows system updates contributed to their browser preference being changed or reset. Those users have fallen into a Reset Trap.
These findings highlight a broader challenge: selecting a preferred browser is only one part of the user experience. Users expect their browser settings to be respected after they make a decision. Users also expect their preferences to persist over time and across devices, applications and services they use every day, but in the Microsoft ecosystem, this is not always the case.
Last week, we explored how the Complexity Barrier prevents users from picking the browser of their choice. But the survey findings also show how even after successfully selecting and using their preferred browser, users continued to experience frustrating technical obstacles. In fact, 2 in 3 users who set a non-Edge browser as their default reported encountering prompts, pop-ups and other experiences discouraging the use of their chosen browser at least once, and 1 in 3 report seeing them every few weeks or more often.
This data indicates that, for users, the ability to choose a browser extends beyond simply selecting a default. It also matters whether or not their preferences are consistently recognized throughout the digital experience.
The Browser Choice Alliance will continue to explore the implications of these findings, examining other aspects of how Windows users experience browser choice, including the challenges consumers encounter when changing browser settings and whether those experiences differ across user groups.
Together, these findings provide new insight into the consumer experience of browser choice and the importance of ensuring users have the ability to select and use the browser that best meets their needs.
To sign up to receive additional updates, click here to receive our newsletter. Further data will be available here once published.