Some 25 organisations (the vast majority of respondents), including the BCA, support the CMA’s eventual Strategic Market Status (“SMS”) designation of Microsoft’s business software ecosystem, and various respondents raise issues concerning Microsoft’s conduct designed to favour its browser, Edge, at the expense of free user choice.
In its response to the CMA’s Invitation to Comment the BCA emphasises that Microsoft’s tactics leverage its dominant Windows OS and M365 productivity software suite to frustrate users’ choice of browsers, thereby damaging the user experience and lowering productivity for millions of businesse+s in the UK. This undermines the efforts of many differentiated, innovative browser developers to compete and reach new audiences, many of them being smaller developers who are especially vulnerable to Microsoft’s tactics.
And the BCA is far from alone in its concerns. In fact, almost a quarter of respondents to the ITC raised concerns with Microsoft’s anti-choice practices in respect of browsers, including the global portfolio rebates that secure blanket exclusive preinstallation of Edge and Microsoft’s dark patterns that prevent users from downloading and effectively using rival browsers. These respondents ranged from independent browsers (like Browserworks, Mozilla, Vivaldi,and Wavebox) to non-governmental bodies like (Open Web Advocacy (“OWA”), and the Browser Choice Alliance (“BCA”), and consulting groups, i.e., Third Stage Consulting, highlighting the broad, cross-party support for intervention.
BCAメンバーは次のように述べています:
“Microsoft’s strategy of resetting browser defaults to Edge and ignoring user choice in key apps in its must-have productivity suite 企業の選択を実質的に制限し、中小企業にとって生産性の流出を生み出しています。. When operating systems override the specialised tools, like Wavebox, that businesses deliberately choose and pay to use, they aren’t just pushing a browser, 効率的に業務を進めようとする小規模企業に、直接的な運用コストと時間の損失を課しているのです。」.” (Wavebox)
“「当社の懸念は明快です。Microsoftは WindowsとMicrosoft 365にわたる長年の支配的地位を利用して自社ブラウザEdgeを優遇し、, Edge, limiting free and effective user choice and undermining fair browser competition.” (BrowserWorks)
“Microsoft is clearly deliberately trying to force users back to Edge, その結果、ユーザーは私たちを責めることになり、仕事や業務上の用途で当社のブラウザを使い続ける可能性は低くなります。 for work and professional reasons. We are glad to see the CMA picking up on these issues, since we are not able to fight back against Microsoft’s massive market power in OS and productivity where Microsoft sets the rules of the game.” (Vivaldi)
BCAと並び、他の市場参加者も自らの意見書の中で同様の懸念を表明しています。
Mozillaは次のように述べています:
“…during the upgrade from Windows 10 to Windows 11, users who have selected alternative default browsers do not have that choice maintained and respected. Instead, they are reset to use Edge as the default, with significant negative impact on usage and retention rates of alternative browsers.”
さらに、
“Microsoft has employed a number of coercive design practices in an attempt to 自社製品へ誘導し、代替製品から遠ざけるため、数々の強圧的なデザイン手法を用いてきました。これらの手法は violate Microsoft’s own design guidelines, strongly suggesting that Microsoft is aware that these choices are not made with the user’s best interests in mind. Further, the fact that many of these deceptive practices disappear when used on recent versions of Microsoft’s software set to the EEA region show that they are 設計に不可避的に伴うものではなく、意図的な設計上の選択であることを示しています。」.”
そして、
“「Microsoftはすでに、ユーザーが意図的に代替ブラウザを選択している場合でさえ、有害なデザイン手法を用いてユーザーを自社のEdgeブラウザへと押し戻しています。」”
Open Web Advocacyは次のように報告しています。
“The evidence set out in this report demonstrates a consistent pattern of behavior by Microsoft that undermines effective browser competition on Windows. これらの慣行は個別のデザイン上の判断にとどまるものではなく、摩擦、ナッジ、技術的制約が相互に結びついた一つのシステムを形成し、ユーザーをMicrosoft Edgeへと誘導する一方で、競合ブラウザの利用をより困難にしています。 Even where individual elements may appear minor in isolation, their cumulative effect is to raise switching costs, distort user choice, and expand Microsoft’s browser market share at the expense of rivals, consumers and businesses.”
さらに、コンピュータ通信産業協会(CCIA)は次のように指摘しています:
“「選択肢の提示方法と既定設定に関して 最も広範な懸念を招いてきたのは、MicrosoftがWindowsにおいてブラウザの選択肢をどのように提示しているかという点です。 比較的単純な事実の通知にとどまるモバイル・エコシステムとは異なり、これらの選択はしばしばセキュリティ更新であるかのように見せかけて提示されます。 商業的な誘導をセキュリティやシステムのメッセージであるかのように装って提示することは、まさに誤解を招きかねない設計であり、 where intervention might produce greater benefits.”
BCAは、CMAによる調査に必要な協力を提供する態勢を整えています。